Saving the Planet Is a Team Effort

How This University Built a Successful Research Partnership

A short, squatty creature, the Texas horned lizard may look unassuming, but it has a secret weapon: the ability to squirt foul-tasting blood from its eyes. Even that skill, however, is no match for humans and habitat loss. The once-plentiful prairie creature is now a threatened species.

Why should people care about what happens to the Texas horned lizard? Put simply, once they’re gone, they’re gone. And, perhaps more importantly—like a canary in a coal mine—the lizard is an indicator species that announces the collapse of a complex habitat.

But there’s hope. A collaboration between Texas Christian University (TCU), the Texas Parks and Wildlife Department (TPWD) and zoo conservation programs is giving the world a way to save the unique animal.

Now, this tag team is sharing their insights on how academia and other organizations can partner for the greater good. While these tips are most applicable to conservation-focused groups like state wildlife departments, non-governmental organizations and nonprofits, many can be applied to any type of collaboration.

Meet the Team

The Geneticist & Boots on the Ground

TCU biology professor Dean Williams, Ph.D., and his graduate students analyze horned lizard DNA. Their findings help conservationists identify populations of lizards that should be bred and reintroduced separately so as to not compromise a vulnerable hatchling’s chances in the wild. TCU students also play a key role in the hatchling release and data collection.  

The Lizard Wrangler

Producing horned lizards in captivity is a delicate endeavor. This is where zoos come in, armed with Williams’ data. Diane Barber, curator of ectotherms for the Fort Worth Zoo, oversees a breeding program involving two full-time attendants and meticulous environmental control and feeding regimens.

The Land Man

Nathan Rains, a wildlife diversity biologist with the Texas Parks & Wildlife Department (TPWD), serves as the project lead for the reintroduction initiative, connecting the work of the zoos and TCU and securing funding. He’s also the glue between researchers and the landowners. TPWD’s land provides conservationists and university researchers with an outdoor laboratory for the hatchling release program.

Members of the research team prepare to reintroduce hatchlings bred in captivity at the Fort Worth Zoo into the Texas wildlands.

Members of the research team prepare to reintroduce hatchlings bred in captivity at the Fort Worth Zoo into the Texas wildlands.

Over the years, the team has released hundreds of horned lizard hatchlings at the Mason Mountain Wildlife Management Area, approximately 100 miles north of San Antonio in the Texas Hill Country.

Over the years, the team has released hundreds of horned lizard hatchlings at the Mason Mountain Wildlife Management Area, approximately 100 miles north of San Antonio in the Texas Hill Country.

The research team uses tiny, lightweight harmonic radar tags to keep tabs on the  hatchlings once they've been released into the wild.

The research team uses tiny, lightweight harmonic radar tags to keep tabs on the  hatchlings once they've been released into the wild.

Harvester ants comprise as much as 90 percent of a horned lizard’s diet, making them vitally important to the species' survival.

Harvester ants comprise as much as 90 percent of a horned lizard’s diet, making them vitally important to the species' survival.

Item 1 of 3

Over the years, the team has released hundreds of horned lizard hatchlings at the Mason Mountain Wildlife Management Area, approximately 100 miles north of San Antonio in the Texas Hill Country.

Over the years, the team has released hundreds of horned lizard hatchlings at the Mason Mountain Wildlife Management Area, approximately 100 miles north of San Antonio in the Texas Hill Country.

The research team uses tiny, lightweight harmonic radar tags to keep tabs on the  hatchlings once they've been released into the wild.

The research team uses tiny, lightweight harmonic radar tags to keep tabs on the  hatchlings once they've been released into the wild.

Harvester ants comprise as much as 90 percent of a horned lizard’s diet, making them vitally important to the species' survival.

Harvester ants comprise as much as 90 percent of a horned lizard’s diet, making them vitally important to the species' survival.

10 Tips for Successful Research Partnerships

1. Look for new opportunities to collaborate.

About a decade ago, TPWD approached Williams about becoming part of the state’s horned lizard captive breeding and reintroduction efforts. The lizard is the official reptile of Texas, so protecting it is a priority for the state-funded agency. It also happens to be TCU’s beloved mascot, and the Fort Worth Zoo, which is literally just down the road from the university and leads captive management efforts, was the first to breed the lizard. These shared connections lit the collaborative spark.

2. Ask how your research could be part of a specific solution.

But while Williams’ genetic research expertise was sought out by both TPWD and the Fort Worth Zoo, he says such an arrangement could be initiated the other way around. “Ask, ‘How could my data answer a particular problem? Who might be the best partner for this?’” Then, academics can consult their networks or search online for other organizations looking for their specific skill sets. “Don’t be shy to reach out and offer your expertise,” suggests Williams.

3. The RFP really does matter. Tie your response tightly to the goal at hand.

It may sound like a given, but the request for proposal (RFP) is more than just a box to check — partnering organizations actually pay close attention to them. Rains and his colleagues are responsible for reviewing stacks of these RFPs for the TPWD and, to keep the process objective, they come with the name of the university and lead researcher blacked out. It’s up to a team to rank them, and there are more proposals than the agency has resources to fund. So, make sure yours stands out. Rains’ advice? “Tie the proposal to a specific objective the partnering organization is looking to achieve. It sounds like common knowledge, but you’d be surprised by how often people don’t do it.”

4. Be willing to help seek funding.

Although partnering organizations may have money to devote to research projects, they are by no means flush with cash. Rains says that the main source of funding for TPWD is pass-through money from the federal government, and many of its grants are $150,000 or less. That’s where entrepreneurial researchers can come in. “If you’re working with an agency or nonprofit, be prepared to get creative. Look at your institutional funding or be willing to secure outside funds yourself,” Williams advises.

For this particular project, Williams was able to secure grant funding from the proceeds collected from conservation license plate sales. And, if funding fails, be open to the more intangible results of collaboration. “If you’re a tenured professor, be willing to do the work for the greater good,” says Williams. “Plus, these collaborations often result in getting published, which is its own currency in academia.”

5.  Acknowledge differences in the work styles outside academia.

“The other organization’s goals and timeframe for getting the project done is often very different from ours in higher education,” says Williams. Some organizations can have much faster turnaround times, which can make involving already busy graduate students and professors a challenge. Talk about working styles and timetables up front.

Juvenile horned frogs bask in the sun at the Fort Worth Zoo. The zoo has bred more than 600 hatchlings since the program began a decade ago.

Juvenile horned frogs bask in the sun at the Fort Worth Zoo. The zoo has bred more than 600 hatchlings since the program began a decade ago.

6. Have a clear charge and make sure it’s communicated to everyone on the team.

To help organize a complex collaboration, it’s important to have a singular mission. In this case, it was understanding how the horned lizard species is genetically structured across Texas. “A lot of academic studies have potential applications, but there’s often a disconnect between the recommendations and the reality of what can be carried out,” Williams explains. “This has especially been a problem in the field of conservation genetics. Having a clear charge from the get-go allows you to provide a more usable end product.”

7. Don’t let theoretical questions distract. Step back, see the big picture and stay focused.

“In genetics, there are a lot of theoretical questions. But these agencies, like TPWD, need something they can put into action,” Williams explains. He appreciates the opportunities to see real applications for TCU’s research, like releasing healthy horned lizard hatchlings into the wild. Instead of going down the rabbit hole of “what if,” step back and stay focused. “Don’t get caught up in the minutia, because that doesn’t necessarily solve the problem at hand,” he advises. “Focus on what the outside group needs, and refer back to the project’s core mission and goals.”

8. Involve graduate students for a win-win.

Williams is pleased with how students have found purpose and discovery in these research projects, and that his lab delivers a scientific workforce that improves the chances for a species in trouble. “We couldn’t do this work without graduate students. They provide the sweat equity,” said Rains. Barber adds that “a graduate student tackling a research question full-time can support our conservation efforts in a very efficient and meaningful way.”

9. Involve your partners from the very beginning all the way up to publication.

Consider listing them as co-authors. The entire point of collaboration is incorporating different strengths and viewpoints to create a better end product. “Involve the other organizations early and often,” says Williams. A recent study showed that including outside collaborators as coauthors—which hasn’t been done too often in the past—results in more specific and actionable recommendations. Williams and Rains are co-authors on the horned lizard genetics study, and they plan to follow the same format for future papers. “Sometimes there is a disconnect between academia and the people tasked with carrying out the recommendations in the field, and this approach can help alleviate that tension,” says Williams.

10. Be patient. The work takes time.

“You have to be willing to be in it for the long haul—it’s not a two-year thing. It’s a spiderweb of new questions,” says Williams. The horned lizard collaboration has already been going on for a decade, and he believes it will continue for at least another one.

But, for now, the culmination of this spirited collaboration takes place early in the morning in the South Texas desert. Scientists and students release the hatchlings—each no bigger than a quarter—and track them with tiny transmitters to follow the creatures’ lop-sided fight against the elements and predators. Each year, the numbers look more promising. And a new cycle of research work begins again.

This content was paid for and created by Texas Christian University. The editorial staff of The Chronicle had no role in its preparation. Find out more about paid content.

Rachel Alenius, a TCU doctoral student in biology, played a key role in performing genetic research and tracking the hatchlings after release.

Rachel Alenius, a TCU doctoral student in biology, played a key role in performing genetic research and tracking the hatchlings after release.