Public-Sector Apprenticeships Are Making Room for Colleges
The West Paris Water District does not have a water operator of its own. The small district in western Maine cannot afford to hire one, so it contracts its operations, and even its bookkeeping and grant applications, to the Maine Rural Water Association. The operator who shows up at its pump house is Matthew Bernier, a registered apprentice with the association.
“It would not be possible for my district, in particular West Paris and many other districts, to put on something like this,” Bernier said of the training he receives. “At the moment, they don’t have the funds to even hire a water operator of their own.”
“Many of the small towns are cash poor; they don’t have a lot of resources,” said Ken Johnson, the association’s apprenticeship coordinator. Many rural utilities, he said, run “in shops with two to four people,” and the average water operator in Maine is 58.
West Paris is a small version of a statewide problem. The same pressure runs through state agencies, town offices, and school districts. Most public employers in Maine have few staff, small budgets, and little time to design and run an apprenticeship program.
Maine’s answer has been to move that administrative work away from the employer. When Joan Dolan took over the Maine Apprenticeship Program, the state had around 700 registered apprentices and “virtually no registered apprenticeship programs within the public sector.” By 2025 it had 3,832 active apprentices, and about 75 percent were registered through intermediary sponsors, organizations that handle the paperwork for many employers at once.
With technical assistance from the Council of State Governments (CSG) and the Urban Institute, Maine has applied that approach to public-sector jobs. The strategy has three parts: Intermediaries carry the administrative load; colleges turn coursework into credit for skills apprentices show on the job; and classroom instruction moves online, so distance matters less in a rural state.
A Job Classification for Learners
Urban and CSG began helping states build public-sector apprenticeships around 2021, with a group of six states that included Maine. In 2022, with grant funding, they started a second phase focused on Maine and Idaho, both largely rural states. The goal in each was to establish three to four new public-sector apprenticeship programs and recruit 20 to 25 apprentices from low-income rural communities to participate. That phase ended in October 2025, and the work continues under a new initiative that will reach more states.
The first fix was inside state government. Maine had no job classification for someone still learning the job. “We have one or multiple for interns but not apprentices,” said Jessica Crosby, director of talent management at Maine’s Bureau of Human Resources. She and Dolan worked with the bureau to create one that fit civil-service rules and collective-bargaining agreements and was broad enough for any agency to use, with pay set at an apprentice wage until the worker qualifies for the full job.
The Department of Health and Human Services piloted it with a nursing apprenticeship at Riverview Psychiatric Center, one of its state hospitals. Once the posting dropped its degree and experience requirements and was listed as an entry-level apprenticeship, “they went from having zero applicants to having over 100 applicants,” said Rebecca Dansereau, an apprenticeship program consultant with the state. According to Dansereau, the Department of Transportation and the Bureau of Marine Patrol have since registered programs of their own.
Letting Intermediaries Carry the Load
A new classification helped state agencies. It did little for a town office with two or three employees. “Maybe they don’t have the manpower to oversee the administrative portion,” Dansereau said, “or maybe they’re just too busy.”
Maine’s answer is the intermediary, or group, sponsor. The intermediary registers the program, works out the schedule of work with the state, registers each apprentice, and handles reporting. Employers sign on beneath it as sub-sponsors and focus on hiring and mentoring.
“It takes my staff the same amount of time to register an intermediary sponsor as it takes to register a single employer sponsor,” Dolan said. Intermediaries in Maine include industry groups like the Associated General Contractors of Maine and the Maine Rural Water Association, as well as community colleges and the nonprofit Educate Maine. In education, where Maine has more than 200 school administrative units, school districts can play the same role for their neighbors.
The approach grew out of a staffing constraint. When Maine received about $12.5 million in federal recovery funds for apprenticeship, the money came with no new state staff, so the labor department spread it across 19 organizations. “Those 19 organizations, many of them have become intermediary sponsors,” Dolan said. “So, they’re touching even more than one single business at a time.”
Maine Rural Water shows how the model works for public employers. It runs the state’s only registered apprenticeship for water and wastewater operators: two years, 4,000 hours of on-the-job training, and 288 hours of instruction. It also takes on the administration for utilities that, Johnson said, often “don’t even have administrative staff, much less a part-time person.” His pitch is simple: “We do all the paperwork. You have to sign one piece of paper. I take it from there.”
|
2 |
4,000 hours of on-the-job training |
288 hours of instruction |
Researchers at the Urban Institute see that as the model’s main advantage for small governments. “It’s especially useful for something like a small water-treatment role, where maybe only one person in a given town holds that job,” said John Marotta, a principal policy associate at Urban. “It doesn’t make a lot of sense for that one town to build and sponsor its own program.”
The program is free for apprentices and costs utilities about $4,000 over two years, which grants can bring down to about $1,500. Grant money that came through CSG and Urban project covered 25 percent of the costs for four apprentices. Three have already earned the licenses they need for full-time careers. One of them, a military veteran who had been working overnight shifts at a truck-stop convenience store, is now a licensed operator in Madison; his military training let him shorten his on-the-job hours.
The intermediary also does things a single utility could not. It runs one cohort a year that brings together apprentices from towns that rarely talk to one another. “West Paris doesn’t talk to Rumford because they don’t need to,” Johnson said. “We’re branching out and building a statewide cohort of collaborative operators.” With help from the labor department, the association has also started a pre-apprenticeship program with the Maine Conservation Corps to widen its pipeline.
Sustaining the state’s side is harder. The Maine Apprenticeship Program has eight full-time staff members, five of them paid for by federal grants. Dolan said the most recent federal base grant covered roughly one position for one year.
Turning Coursework Into Competency Credit
The second part of the strategy asks colleges to count what apprentices already do at work toward a credential, reducing the time a person must, in Dolan’s words, “sit in seat.” The most developed example is for educational technicians, or ed techs, who often earn “barely above minimum wage,” she said, and cannot afford to quit for a degree. Through the Maine Community College system, Dolan said, ed-tech apprentices can “keep their job, get paid, take half as many courses as is typically required” to move up. The pathway runs from 60 credits to 90 to 120 and full teacher certification.
At the University of Maine, faculty members worked with Amy Cyr, a literacy coach and apprenticeship navigator for the Old Town district, to rethink the program. “They actually deconstructed almost 10 courses, and they looked at all of the things that an ed tech does on the job,” Cyr said.
Lacie Velasquez, an ed tech in Old Town, had earned an associate degree at Beal College, now Beal University, in Bangor, but those credits did not transfer when she enrolled at the University of Maine at Augusta. “I’m starting over. I’m taking classes I’ve already done,” she remembered thinking. Through the apprenticeship, the University of Maine matched her 89 credits against the schedule of work, leaving her only her junior and senior years to complete.
Her mentor teacher checked off skills in an app as she demonstrated them, and she could student-teach while still being paid. Without that, she said, “that would have been the end of the road for me.” She graduated in May.
Her experience also shows what still needs to be built. Velasquez’s transcript “looks wonky,” Velasquez said, to hiring schools because it does not list every course her credits represent, and she has not yet landed a teaching job. “I don’t know if they were like, ‘What the heck is this? Is she really qualified?’” she said. Her suggestion: Have mentors automatically write a letter explaining the apprenticeship that graduates can attach to job applications.
Taking the Classroom Online
The third part of the strategy addresses distance. Travel from one end of Maine to the other “can be almost eight to 10 hours,” said Johnson at Maine Rural Water. Dansereau, who has worked in apprenticeships for a decade, said online classes had been “a game changer”: more employers register programs because apprentices no longer have to drive an hour to class.
For Maine Rural Water, online delivery also solves a staffing problem. “If you lose 25 percent of your work force all of a sudden to come to training, that’s significant,” Johnson said. Classes run on Zoom during work hours, utilities pay apprentices to attend, and every session is recorded so operators called out to an emergency can catch up.
Online does not mean self-paced. Many similar programs in other states, Johnson said, are “a list of online courses that you take by yourself.” His sessions are live, apprentices have his cell number, and he teaches what he called application math, with no x or y. Apprentices take the easiest license exam first. For apprentices in his program, “‘I can do this turns’ into ‘I want to do this,’” he said.
Bernier, the apprentice at Maine Rural Water, said the freedom to test when ready made a difference. “At school, the exams happen when they happen,” he said. “Whereas with this model you get to feel comfortable in your studies and then take the exam.”
Under the old approach, Johnson said, new hires got technical manuals and two years to earn a license, and the first-try pass rate on state exams averaged 37 percent. Under the new model, every one of the association’s apprentices has passed on the first attempt. The program has roughly tripled in three years, to about 15 apprentices.
Wendy Kostenbauder, program manager for the Maine Apprenticeship Program, said asynchronous coursework lets a working student “sit at their computer after the kids are in bed and finish a class.”
Access still depends on a connection. In 2025, 8 percent of Maine locations lacked broadband-level internet service, according to the Maine Development Foundation. The state is working on that gap: In February, federal regulators approved Maine’s plan to spend $272 million connecting about 22,000 more homes and businesses. But new lines take years to build, and the programs in this story point to ways apprenticeship providers can work around the gap in the meantime.
One is to schedule instruction on the clock. When classes happen during paid work hours, apprentices are not relying on their home connections alone, and recordings let them catch up later, said Johnson. Another is to pay for support, not just software. At Washington County Community College, Nichole Sawyer, dean of work-force development, used state capacity grants to hire work-force student navigators who help rural adult learners troubleshoot technology, replace broken laptops, and find their way through online portals. A third is to use public infrastructure that already exists. The Maine Connectivity Authority has financed “connectivity hubs” at libraries, community centers, and municipal buildings that offer work-force training and one-on-one technology help — places where an apprentice without reliable service at home can log on.
What Scaling Looks Like Next
Maine’s experience suggests that scaling public-sector apprenticeship depends less on persuading employers one at a time than on building shared infrastructure they can join: a job classification any agency can use, intermediaries that carry the paperwork, credit that follows the apprentice, and instruction that reaches rural workers. “Apprenticeship doesn’t cost as much as we thought it would cost to do,” Dolan said.
Johnson warned against growing faster than quality allows. “You have to build your apprenticeship by success rates,” he said. Most of the association’s new apprentices now come through word of mouth among superintendents. Velasquez’s experience points to one more piece: employers who understand what an apprenticeship credential represents.
Scaling across government also takes patience. “One big lesson is that it takes a lot of time to convince people at various levels,” Marotta said. Andrew Campbell, a policy program manager at Urban, added that “a lot of the barriers come down to decentralized decision-making,” across state agencies and levels of local government. CSG and Urban are now taking those lessons to other states. “We’re going to be able to work with eight to 10 states over the next few years,” said Lindsay Lucas, deputy program director at the Council of State Governments.
Dolan described the goal with the image of a four-legged stool: college, the military, going directly to work, and apprenticeship. “Unless I’ve got all four legs firmly touching the ground,” she said, “then it’s not a solid base from which to build a career.”
This article was produced by Chronicle Brand Studio.
©2026 by The Chronicle of Higher Education Inc. All rights reserved. This material may not be reproduced without prior written permission of The Chronicle. For permission requests, contact us at copyright@chronicle.com.

