As higher ed looks for better pathways to connect graduates with employment opportunities and reduce the cost of college, many institutions are testing a new offering: the apprenticeship degree, which combines paid work for an employer with academic study. It’s a popular model in parts of Europe that’s beginning to exist in the United States, especially in fields like education, nursing, and manufacturing. Some see potential to expand the approach to many other professional fields, opening up academe to Americans who can’t afford to stop working to attend college.

To explore this topic, The Chronicle, with support from Ascendium, held a virtual forum on September 29. Panelists discussed how to build apprenticeships, internships, and stackable credentials that lead somewhere, where community colleges fit as apprenticeships expand beyond traditional trades, and how to translate campus-level innovation into equitable, systemwide change. 

The following comments, edited for clarity and length, represent key takeaways from the forum. To hear the full discussion, watch the recorded webinar here.

Ian Wilhelm

Deputy Managing Editor

The Chronicle of Higher Education

Keith Curry

President

Compton College

Miles Feroli

Executive Director of Work-Force and Economic Development

Kentucky Council on Postsecondary Education

Matt Gianneschi

President

Colorado Mountain College

Nerita Hughes

President, Bay de Noc Community College

Joe E. Ross

President and Chief Executive Officer

Reach University

Keith Curry: President Ross, would you tell us about your work on apprenticeships at Reach University?

Joe E. Ross: Reach is the first institution dedicated entirely to turning jobs into degrees instead of the other way around. We call our model an apprenticeship degree. We currently serve 3,700 full-time students who are all full-time employees of their employers. We’re in 10 states, delivering associate, bachelor’s, and master’s degrees. The workplace is our campus.

Curry: How would you describe what makes your program relevant, flexible, affordable, and otherwise beneficial for students?

Ross: Well, our model comes out of traditions of apprenticeship that go back centuries. Three things set it apart from a conventional degree, which I call the ABCs: A is for affordability, ideally without debt as students are learning and earning. B is for being based in the workplace, as the program starts with a job and is designed to end with a better job. C is for credit for learning at work. 

When you combine those three things, you overcome barriers for workers to achieve postsecondary success. It makes work, learning, and life go together. Many students have given up on higher ed — even if maybe they’ve had a few years of college — and apprenticeship degrees offer the opportunity to open up whole new pathways into postsecondary education. Surveys show there are about 50 million workers in the United States who don’t have a degree but wish they did.

Ian Wilhelm: Do you start with employers to identify ways to create apprenticeships within existing jobs? 

Ross: We start in the fields of teaching and health care, with professions that require a degree as an entry ticket. Employers need a reason to be in a partnership. Hospitals are seeing once-in-a-lifetime vacancies. Schools are facing persistent teacher vacancies. They need people who are qualified to meet licensure requirements, which often involves having a degree. That said, in Germany and England, we’re seeing apprenticeship degrees across every imaginable occupation — medical doctors, management consultants, and everything in between. You’re seeing workplaces incentivized to work with higher ed to turn entry-level jobs into degree pathways. 

Curry: How might this model look at a college with a traditional student body ages 18 to 23? 

Ross: That’s a fair question. In our program, our average age is currently 37. There are a lot of incumbent workers — paraeducators and certified nursing assistants — who, given this opportunity, become your first wave of enrollment. But as that gets to scale, we’re beginning to see employers look to entry-level talent.

Curry: How do you connect with employers?

Ross: There’s a tremendous amount of risk in setting up an apprenticeship degree or any work-based program — if you don’t engage employers. Employers don’t come to Reach looking for our graduates. They come bringing us our students. It’s with employer partners that we recruit students. In fact, they do a lot of recruiting, which lowers the cost of recruitment.

Listen to your employers. You can’t really design these programs if they’re not at the table with you. We haven’t mentioned AI, but we need to start asking what makes us human, and what are the skills humans possess that AI doesn’t.

Curry: Colleges are being asked to offer more apprenticeships, internships, and short-term credentials. How do you decide which opportunities are worthwhile and then design them well?

Matt Gianneschi: Setting aside traditional transfer degrees, all other credentials offered at our college have a work-based learning component to them. We’ve built that into everything we do. We’ve also tried to make sure every program we have offers an experiential opportunity. We’re learning that students today value experience as much as the credential they’re earning. They want to have something on their résumé that matters to employers. We also want to make sure we have stackable credentials that lead to industry certifications.

Nerita Hughes: We’re aligning with our work force. We’ve been able to work with our manufacturers on apprenticeships and internships. We’ve done a lot around the trades. You also have to ask whether what you’re offering is going to get someone a sustainable, living-wage job or graduate them into poverty. 

Partnerships with employers have to be mutually beneficial. There’s a manufacturer within walking distance of our college, and I learned we weren’t really that connected. We should be asking whether a partnership is sustainable or just a one-term thing.

Curry: What must be true for paid work to count meaningfully toward a degree?

Ross: It’s about theory and practice. You also need time for reflection and sensemaking — making sense of work. That can happen in the workplace with a mentor or in a seminar online. Then you need assessment of competencies — of skills on the job. One thing we know about working adults — maybe all adults — is that they can have cognitive overload, so one of the things we did in our bachelor of arts in liberal studies for teachers was to design a guided pathway that felt like one subject at a time. It was actually 15 credits at a time, but it would be, for example, a whole semester of social science or of math. That helped working adults.

Miles Feroli: I’m part of our state’s higher-education executive-officer agency, which is really an intermediary between state government and our public postsecondary institutions. Our charge is to make sure we’re all singing from the same hymnal. We set a strategic agenda and make sure everyone is complying. Education should not be the vehicle that just drops students off at the work destination. It’s a reciprocal partnership. My unit is in charge of building out relationships with employers to more accurately understand what they’re needing, and to also work with our institutions of higher ed to have them be potential employers and produce high-quality, adaptive talent. 

We have what we call the Kentucky Graduate Profile. It’s something we built with employers, state government, and institutions of higher ed — a list of 10 skills all students will graduate with, including problem solving, collaboration, quantitative reasoning. This framework allows institutions, employers, and students to all speak the same language. 

Where we’ve found some hiccups is when some employers say, “I can’t possibly take on an apprentice or intern. I’ve got five employees, and we’re all strapped.” We’re really leaning into public-private partnerships. One is with our Healthcare Workforce Investment Fund — a state appropriation of about $10 million, which can be matched by employers to provide money to students. We’ve been seeing students leave their programs with little or no debt, and participating students are required to be hired by the partner.  

Curry: How do you work with trades and unions in your efforts?

Hughes: Our college, in 2024, met with what’s called the Upper Peninsula Construction Council to see how to create an apprenticeship model allowing for people seeking journeyman status or who’ve already completed a registered apprenticeship. We worked with several different trades. They’d get 45 credits, with a match of the work from the apprenticeship and 15 general-education credits where they had to take. This then turned into something greater, where the Michigan Community Colleges Association has worked with the American Council on Education and our state on a statewide apprenticeship program for college credit. Of the 31 community colleges we have in Michigan, 28 have signed on to this articulation with the trades.

Gianneschi: Colorado is a right-to-work state, so I don’t want to overstate the degree to which we work with unions. We were the first college in the nation to have a teacher-education apprenticeship authorized, and that’s working quite well. We’ve been able to complement an existing work force. We’ve recently received approval for an early-childhood, apprenticeship-style program as well.

Feroli: We’re also a right-to-work state, and our engagement with trades is quite robust, though not so much with unions. If you have a certain amount of hours and classroom participation, that will get you a two-year degree in apprenticeship studies. We have a really effective model called Kentucky Fame — the Federation for Advanced Manufacturing Education. That’s a partnership that started with Toyota and our Bluegrass Community and Technical College in 2010 and has now expanded to 17 different states. Students work three days a week and get paid a full-time salary and then go to school two days a week as well. They eventually graduate with their associate degree in advanced manufacturing technician. We’re really invested in the trades, and we’re excited to grow more in that space. 

Ross: I’d encourage any institution that wants to meet other institutions working on apprenticeship degrees to be in touch with Reach University's National Center for the Apprenticeship Degree. We like to say it's R&D, meaning “rip off and duplicate,” and one of the things you can rip off is how we’ve embedded liberal arts into our behavioral-health associate degree. There was a semester in which we had to teach psychology while people were working in addiction clinics, and so we paired Psych 1, 2, and 3 with the literature of mental illness as an intentional pathway design. That type of innovation is something that many institutions are engaged in, and we can do best by learning from each other.

Keith Curry: President Ross, would you tell us about your work on apprenticeships at Reach University?

Joe E. Ross: Reach is the first institution dedicated entirely to turning jobs into degrees instead of the other way around. We call our model an apprenticeship degree. We currently serve 3,700 full-time students who are all full-time employees of their employers. We’re in 10 states, delivering associate, bachelor’s, and master’s degrees. The workplace is our campus.

Curry: How would you describe what makes your program relevant, flexible, affordable, and otherwise beneficial for students?

Ross: Well, our model comes out of traditions of apprenticeship that go back centuries. Three things set it apart from a conventional degree, which I call the ABCs: A is for affordability, ideally without debt as students are learning and earning. B is for being based in the workplace, as the program starts with a job and is designed to end with a better job. C is for credit for learning at work. 

When you combine those three things, you overcome barriers for workers to achieve postsecondary success. It makes work, learning, and life go together. Many students have given up on higher ed — even if maybe they’ve had a few years of college — and apprenticeship degrees offer the opportunity to open up whole new pathways into postsecondary education. Surveys show there are about 50 million workers in the United States who don’t have a degree but wish they did.

Ian Wilhelm: Do you start with employers to identify ways to create apprenticeships within existing jobs? 

Ross: We start in the fields of teaching and health care, with professions that require a degree as an entry ticket. Employers need a reason to be in a partnership. Hospitals are seeing once-in-a-lifetime vacancies. Schools are facing persistent teacher vacancies. They need people who are qualified to meet licensure requirements, which often involves having a degree. That said, in Germany and England, we’re seeing apprenticeship degrees across every imaginable occupation — medical doctors, management consultants, and everything in between. You’re seeing workplaces incentivized to work with higher ed to turn entry-level jobs into degree pathways. 

Curry: How might this model look at a college with a traditional student body ages 18 to 23? 

Ross: That’s a fair question. In our program, our average age is currently 37. There are a lot of incumbent workers — paraeducators and certified nursing assistants — who, given this opportunity, become your first wave of enrollment. But as that gets to scale, we’re beginning to see employers look to entry-level talent.

Curry: How do you connect with employers?

Ross: There’s a tremendous amount of risk in setting up an apprenticeship degree or any work-based program — if you don’t engage employers. Employers don’t come to Reach looking for our graduates. They come bringing us our students. It’s with employer partners that we recruit students. In fact, they do a lot of recruiting, which lowers the cost of recruitment.

Listen to your employers. You can’t really design these programs if they’re not at the table with you. We haven’t mentioned AI, but we need to start asking what makes us human, and what are the skills humans possess that AI doesn’t.

Curry: Colleges are being asked to offer more apprenticeships, internships, and short-term credentials. How do you decide which opportunities are worthwhile and then design them well?

Matt Gianneschi: Setting aside traditional transfer degrees, all other credentials offered at our college have a work-based learning component to them. We’ve built that into everything we do. We’ve also tried to make sure every program we have offers an experiential opportunity. We’re learning that students today value experience as much as the credential they’re earning. They want to have something on their résumé that matters to employers. We also want to make sure we have stackable credentials that lead to industry certifications.

Nerita Hughes: We’re aligning with our work force. We’ve been able to work with our manufacturers on apprenticeships and internships. We’ve done a lot around the trades. You also have to ask whether what you’re offering is going to get someone a sustainable, living-wage job or graduate them into poverty. Partnerships with employers have to be mutually beneficial. There’s a manufacturer within walking distance of our college, and I learned we weren’t really that connected. We should be asking whether a partnership is sustainable or just a one-term thing.

Curry: What must be true for paid work to count meaningfully toward a degree?

Ross: It’s about theory and practice. You also need time for reflection and sensemaking — making sense of work. That can happen in the workplace with a mentor or in a seminar online. Then you need assessment of competencies — of skills on the job. 

One thing we know about working adults — maybe all adults — is that they can have cognitive overload, so one of the things we did in our bachelor of arts in liberal studies for teachers was to design a guided pathway that felt like one subject at a time. It was actually 15 credits at a time, but it would be, for example, a whole semester of social science or of math. That helped working adults.

Miles Feroli: I’m part of our state’s higher-education executive-officer agency, which is really an intermediary between state government and our public postsecondary institutions. Our charge is to make sure we’re all singing from the same hymnal. We set a strategic agenda and make sure everyone is complying. Education should not be the vehicle that just drops students off at the work destination. It’s a reciprocal partnership. My unit is in charge of building out relationships with employers to more accurately understand what they’re needing, and to also work with our institutions of higher ed to have them be potential employers and produce high-quality, adaptive talent. 

We have what we call the Kentucky Graduate Profile. It’s something we built with employers, state government, and institutions of higher ed — a list of 10 skills all students will graduate with, including problem solving, collaboration, quantitative reasoning. This framework allows institutions, employers, and students to all speak the same language. 

Where we’ve found some hiccups is when some employers say, “I can’t possibly take on an apprentice or intern. I’ve got five employees, and we’re all strapped.” We’re really leaning into public-private partnerships. One is with our Healthcare Workforce Investment Fund — a state appropriation of about $10 million, which can be matched by employers to provide money to students. We’ve been seeing students leave their programs with little or no debt, and participating students are required to be hired by the partner.  

Curry: How do you work with trades and unions in your efforts?

Hughes: Our college, in 2024, met with what’s called the Upper Peninsula Construction Council to see how to create an apprenticeship model allowing for people seeking journeyman status or who’ve already completed a registered apprenticeship. We worked with several different trades. They’d get 45 credits, with a match of the work from the apprenticeship and 15 general-education credits where they had to take. This then turned into something greater, where the Michigan Community Colleges Association has worked with the American Council on Education and our state on a statewide apprenticeship program for college credit. Of the 31 community colleges we have in Michigan, 28 have signed on to this articulation with the trades.

Gianneschi: Colorado is a right-to-work state, so I don’t want to overstate the degree to which we work with unions. We were the first college in the nation to have a teacher-education apprenticeship authorized, and that’s working quite well. We’ve been able to complement an existing work force. We’ve recently received approval for an early-childhood, apprenticeship-style program as well.

Feroli: We’re also a right-to-work state, and our engagement with trades is quite robust, though not so much with unions. If you have a certain amount of hours and classroom participation, that will get you a two-year degree in apprenticeship studies. We have a really effective model called Kentucky Fame — the Federation for Advanced Manufacturing Education. That’s a partnership that started with Toyota and our Bluegrass Community and Technical College in 2010 and has now expanded to 17 different states. Students work three days a week and get paid a full-time salary and then go to school two days a week as well. They eventually graduate with their associate degree in advanced manufacturing technician. We’re really invested in the trades, and we’re excited to grow more in that space. 

Ross: I’d encourage any institution that wants to meet other institutions working on apprenticeship degrees to be in touch with Reach University's National Center for the Apprenticeship Degree. We like to say it's R&D, meaning “rip off and duplicate,” and one of the things you can rip off is how we’ve embedded liberal arts into our behavioral-health associate degree. There was a semester in which we had to teach psychology while people were working in addiction clinics, and so we paired Psych 1, 2, and 3 with the literature of mental illness as an intentional pathway design. That type of innovation is something that many institutions are engaged in, and we can do best by learning from each other.

0

This Key Takeaways was produced by Chronicle Intelligence. Please contact CI@chronicle.com with questions or comments.

©2026 by The Chronicle of Higher Education Inc. All rights reserved. This material may not be reproduced without prior written permission of The Chronicle. For permission requests, contact us at copyright@chronicle.com.