The pressure on higher education to prove its worth has never been greater. For community colleges and other broad-access institutions that center on economic mobility, the stakes are especially high.
But with public skepticism rising and only a fraction of nondegree credentials delivering real wage gains, that promise is harder to keep — and harder to communicate.
To explore this challenge further, The Chronicle held a virtual forum on June 30 called “Working for Change: Improving Student ROI and Economic Mobility.” The panel examined how institutions can define economic mobility in ways that reflect the realities of today’s diverse student populations — including adult learners, working students, first-generation students, and those from low-income backgrounds — what data institutions and state systems should be tracking, how community colleges can balance rapid labor-market responsiveness with their broader civic mission; and how college leaders can communicate institutional value to students, employers, policymakers, and the public.
The following comments, edited for clarity and length, represent key takeaways from the forum. To hear the full discussion, watch the recorded webinar here.
Keith Curry (moderator)
President
Compton College
Graham Vyse (moderator)
Staff Reporter
The Chronicle of Higher Education
Kimberly Beatty
Chancellor
Metropolitan Community College, in Missouri
Steven Gentile
Executive Director
Tennessee Higher Education Commission
Stacy Klippenstein
President
College of Southern Nevada
Kenyatta Lovett
Principal
Higher Education Strategy Group
Russell Lowery-Hart
Chancellor
Austin Community College District
Ray Martinez III
President
Texas Association of Community Colleges
Chris White
Vice Chancellor for Work-Force Development and Upward Mobility
State University of New York
Keith Curry: When I think about return on investment, economic mobility, I think about the value proposition and how we articulate our programs to our community and to our stakeholders. How do we talk about some of our programs that might not have that value but are needed?
I think about it as an institution, not just on the academic-program side, but also the student-support services. How are we supporting our students with financial aid, scholarships? What does the total cost of attendance really look like for our students? How are we meeting their basic needs? How do we talk to students about the value of the program? How do we advise students about how loans could impact them as it relates to their earnings over time?
We're really thinking about it as an institutional conversation versus one area within the institution, and breaking down those silos. And then you can start looking at it by age, race, and gender, too. It puts pressure on some states, like California, to make sure we have regular employment data about our students so we can move faster in supporting them.
I also want to be able to see students from the community that I serve able to buy homes within the community. We have to be very mindful that it's hard for some individuals, especially in California, to be able to buy a home within Los Angeles County. Economic mobility is to be able to buy stuff and own your own property within your community. What does that look like, and how do we support students to be able to do that?
How should colleges and state systems define economic mobility in a way that reflects the lived realities of today's students?
Kenyatta Lovett: Attainment has been the dominant force driving higher education up until probably a couple years ago. But we see some opportunity to think about things beyond attainment — economic value over all, not just to the students, but also to local economies — and also wealth accumulation.
Second, grounding benchmarks in local economies. The local economic context for Compton College will look a lot different than other parts of L.A. County or California, and having a conversation very specific to that with faculty, with leaders, with employers on what value means within the Compton region is important.
The last thing is validating all pathways. We are starting to grapple with simplifying what the value equation really looks like. It centers on affordability and applicability. When you think about pathways, how do you improve affordability for students, and also how do you improve the applicability of those credentials as they walk across that convention stage and into the job marketplace?
Graham Vyse: What data should colleges and states use to understand whether students are experiencing real economic gains after completion?
Ray Martinez: In Texas, we've given a lot of thought to ROI and to economic mobility. We have defined what is a credential of value for each of the credentials under our funding model. But I have to be honest about where the framework in Texas still has room to grow. Texas is a state of immense geographic and economic diversity. The labor market in El Paso is not the labor market in Houston, nor does it resemble the labor market in East Texas, in Texarkana, or, of course, the panhandle. So how do we define wage thresholds that are largely anchored in statewide medians? A statewide median can obscure as much as it reveals. A credential that clears the bar on self-sufficient wage in the Dallas-Fort Worth metroplex may not reflect genuine economic mobility for a student that's completing that same credential in a small rural county.
We're not there yet, but we're moving towards defining ROI on a more regional context, not just a statewide one. But that also speaks to us having the data, the wage and employment data at a more granular level that allows us to make informed decisions around ROI and economic mobility.
Steven Gentile: Opportunity costs become even more important for working adults, low-income students, first-generation students. What are they giving up in order to be in school to begin with? Putting the salary, the wage, showing what they can get — that's important — but measuring the amount of excess credit accumulation, making sure we can minimize that. Are we taking in better credits for prior learning assessment to help minimize the time to degree? That's the data that we need.
Curry: Do you feel that the ROI, economic-mobility conversation has forced you to look at your entire organization and have different types of conversations?
Martinez: There's no question that the transformative change that we made in 2023 here in Texas was to fund our 50 community-college districts, not based on enrollment, which had been going on for decades, but based entirely upon performance or outcomes. Twenty years ago, 25 years ago, we were focused on access. Then we became focused upon success, put wraparound services and resources around our students to make sure that they get to completion. Then it was all about completion. Where we are focused now is, yes, it's about completion, but completion with value.
Vyse: What is one policy lever or institutional practice that could increase that return on investment?
Chris White: We have a goal in New York that all of our students have some kind of experiential learning before they graduate. Engineering, business have a lot of easier, straightforward connections. But we have a strategic mission to be more widespread than that, so we’re thinking about arts and humanities, social sciences, focusing especially on students in our more rural campuses and rural areas that don't have access to public transportation or transportation themselves. What do those experiences look like? How can we still form that connection to the real world, help them build relationships, help them build social capital? We’re working to help them connect into networking, which we know from many, many years of business surveys is the fundamental thing that businesses use to hire. We really want to try to weave that in as much as possible.
Gentile: We have many opportunities to deploy this in policy levers due to innovative policies that have come forward. An example would be Workforce Pell, or 90 credit-hour bachelor’s degrees. I know a lot of states are finding ways to welcome these. What we're doing here in Tennessee is using the opportunity with Workforce Pell and 90 credit-hour bachelor’s degrees to employ higher expectations for stackable credentials. We want to embed those credentials with certificates that can stack and help paint a way for students where their education might pick up down the road.
Curry: What does it look like to make economic mobility a collegewide strategy rather than a responsibility of one division, office, or program?
Kimberly Beatty: It can't be owned in one office. A strategy has to live in your plan and the budget. We take a holistic approach. You first have to listen to the community. We have a strong process of developing a business case. So, what is that ROI? How much are they going to earn? What gap is filled in the community? Because sometimes it's not just about the money. Early childhood is a program that doesn't pay a whole lot, but we can't eliminate programs like that because it fills a different type of ROI in terms of that gap.
After we do that business case, we gather the data. It does have to make sense for the institution. Many health programs don't make sense for the institution from a cost standpoint, because they're so expensive to run, or manufacturing and those types of programs can be expensive. But holistically, in terms of what that ROI and what the contribution is to the ecosystem, we build that case and present it to our board. It's a holistic approach, because strategy is not what you fund, it's what you measure.
Russell Lowery-Hart: The bottom line is that it has to be the essence of who we are. It's not an add-on. It's not a presidential priority. It has got to be integrated into every part of the college, the budgeting, the program reviews, and not just for the programs themselves. How are advisers engaging with the ROI discussion when they're helping map out pathways? How is marketing communicating the programs with the highest ROI? How are faculty engaging and messaging those programs whose ROI is maybe less financial but more communal and more personal. There isn't a part of the college that shouldn't be integrated into making decisions about and communicating with students about economic mobility and how we're structuring ourselves to ensure that it happens.
Curry: How can CEOs communicate the value of their institution to students, families, and employers, policymakers, and taxpayers?
Stacy Klippenstein: Start with the student. What's the potential ROI? What's the time it takes? Is there transferability? What is the end outcome within that program? We're trying to share with them that we're offering flexible pathways, stackable programs. There's an entry, and there's an exit. You can come back on, and off-ramp, on-ramp. Being clear with messaging so that a student and a family can look at and go, “Huh, community college is affordable. It's accessible. I got a pathway right in front of me, a navigator that's with me along the way, all the support services. I have financial aid. I have scholarships. I have all these opportunities.”
Then from the position of the employers, we're offering a skilled individual, and if we do it correctly — if we're doing it in conjunction with them, with curriculum development, short-term program pathways in the noncredit side and the for-credit side, and they're stackable — we're approaching it from that, and we're listening to the industry.
When I get into the policymakers and the taxpayers and so forth, it's really about that ROI for every single dollar that we are getting from the State of Nevada. We know at College of Southern Nevada, for every single dollar that we get from the state, it's a $2.10 return, and we just received that data on economic impact.
Keith Curry: When I think about return on investment, economic mobility, I think about the value proposition and how we articulate our programs to our community and to our stakeholders. How do we talk about some of our programs that might not have that value but are needed?
I think about it as an institution, not just on the academic-program side, but also the student-support services. How are we supporting our students with financial aid, scholarships? What does the total cost of attendance really look like for our students? How are we meeting their basic needs? How do we talk to students about the value of the program? How do we advise students about how loans could impact them as it relates to their earnings over time?
We're really thinking about it as an institutional conversation versus one area within the institution, and breaking down those silos. And then you can start looking at it by age, race, and gender, too. It puts pressure on some states, like California, to make sure we have regular employment data about our students so we can move faster in supporting them.
I also want to be able to see students from the community that I serve able to buy homes within the community. We have to be very mindful that it's hard for some individuals, especially in California, to be able to buy a home within Los Angeles County. Economic mobility is to be able to buy stuff and own your own property within your community. What does that look like, and how do we support students to be able to do that?
How should colleges and state systems define economic mobility in a way that reflects the lived realities of today's students?
Kenyatta Lovett: Attainment has been the dominant force driving higher education up until probably a couple years ago. But we see some opportunity to think about things beyond attainment — economic value over all, not just to the students, but also to local economies — and also wealth accumulation.
Second, grounding benchmarks in local economies. The local economic context for Compton College will look a lot different than other parts of L.A. County or California, and having a conversation very specific to that with faculty, with leaders, with employers on what value means within the Compton region is important.
The last thing is validating all pathways. We are starting to grapple with simplifying what the value equation really looks like. It centers on affordability and applicability. When you think about pathways, how do you improve affordability for students, and also how do you improve the applicability of those credentials as they walk across that convention stage and into the job marketplace?
Graham Vyse: What data should colleges and states use to understand whether students are experiencing real economic gains after completion?
Ray Martinez: In Texas, we've given a lot of thought to ROI and to economic mobility. We have defined what is a credential of value for each of the credentials under our funding model. But I have to be honest about where the framework in Texas still has room to grow. Texas is a state of immense geographic and economic diversity. The labor market in El Paso is not the labor market in Houston, nor does it resemble the labor market in East Texas, in Texarkana, or, of course, the panhandle. So how do we define wage thresholds that are largely anchored in statewide medians? A statewide median can obscure as much as it reveals. A credential that clears the bar on self-sufficient wage in the Dallas-Fort Worth metroplex may not reflect genuine economic mobility for a student that's completing that same credential in a small rural county.
We're not there yet, but we're moving towards defining ROI on a more regional context, not just a statewide one. But that also speaks to us having the data, the wage and employment data at a more granular level that allows us to make informed decisions around ROI and economic mobility.
Steven Gentile: Opportunity costs become even more important for working adults, low-income students, first-generation students. What are they giving up in order to be in school to begin with? Putting the salary, the wage, showing what they can get — that's important — but measuring the amount of excess credit accumulation, making sure we can minimize that. Are we taking in better credits for prior learning assessment to help minimize the time to degree? That's the data that we need.
Curry: Do you feel that the ROI, economic-mobility conversation has forced you to look at your entire organization and have different types of conversations?
Martinez: There's no question that the transformative change that we made in 2023 here in Texas was to fund our 50 community-college districts, not based on enrollment, which had been going on for decades, but based entirely upon performance or outcomes. Twenty years ago, 25 years ago, we were focused on access. Then we became focused upon success, put wraparound services and resources around our students to make sure that they get to completion. Then it was all about completion. Where we are focused now is, yes, it's about completion, but completion with value.
Vyse: What is one policy lever or institutional practice that could increase that return on investment?
Chris White: We have a goal in New York that all of our students have some kind of experiential learning before they graduate. Engineering, business have a lot of easier, straightforward connections. But we have a strategic mission to be more widespread than that, so we’re thinking about arts and humanities, social sciences, focusing especially on students in our more rural campuses and rural areas that don't have access to public transportation or transportation themselves. What do those experiences look like? How can we still form that connection to the real world, help them build relationships, help them build social capital? We’re working to help them connect into networking, which we know from many, many years of business surveys is the fundamental thing that businesses use to hire. We really want to try to weave that in as much as possible.
Gentile: We have many opportunities to deploy this in policy levers due to innovative policies that have come forward. An example would be Workforce Pell, or 90 credit-hour bachelor’s degrees. I know a lot of states are finding ways to welcome these. What we're doing here in Tennessee is using the opportunity with Workforce Pell and 90 credit-hour bachelor’s degrees to employ higher expectations for stackable credentials. We want to embed those credentials with certificates that can stack and help paint a way for students where their education might pick up down the road.
Curry: What does it look like to make economic mobility a collegewide strategy rather than a responsibility of one division, office, or program?
Kimberly Beatty: It can't be owned in one office. A strategy has to live in your plan and the budget. We take a holistic approach. You first have to listen to the community. We have a strong process of developing a business case. So, what is that ROI? How much are they going to earn? What gap is filled in the community? Because sometimes it's not just about the money. Early childhood is a program that doesn't pay a whole lot, but we can't eliminate programs like that because it fills a different type of ROI in terms of that gap.
After we do that business case, we gather the data. It does have to make sense for the institution. Many health programs don't make sense for the institution from a cost standpoint, because they're so expensive to run, or manufacturing and those types of programs can be expensive. But holistically, in terms of what that ROI and what the contribution is to the ecosystem, we build that case and present it to our board. It's a holistic approach, because strategy is not what you fund, it's what you measure.
Russell Lowery-Hart: The bottom line is that it has to be the essence of who we are. It's not an add-on. It's not a presidential priority. It has got to be integrated into every part of the college, the budgeting, the program reviews, and not just for the programs themselves. How are advisers engaging with the ROI discussion when they're helping map out pathways? How is marketing communicating the programs with the highest ROI? How are faculty engaging and messaging those programs whose ROI is maybe less financial but more communal and more personal. There isn't a part of the college that shouldn't be integrated into making decisions about and communicating with students about economic mobility and how we're structuring ourselves to ensure that it happens.
Curry: How can CEOs communicate the value of their institution to students, families, and employers, policymakers, and taxpayers?
Stacy Klippenstein: Start with the student. What's the potential ROI? What's the time it takes? Is there transferability? What is the end outcome within that program? We're trying to share with them that we're offering flexible pathways, stackable programs. There's an entry, and there's an exit. You can come back on, and off-ramp, on-ramp. Being clear with messaging so that a student and a family can look at and go, “Huh, community college is affordable. It's accessible. I got a pathway right in front of me, a navigator that's with me along the way, all the support services. I have financial aid. I have scholarships. I have all these opportunities.”
Then from the position of the employers, we're offering a skilled individual, and if we do it correctly — if we're doing it in conjunction with them, with curriculum development, short-term program pathways in the noncredit side and the for-credit side, and they're stackable — we're approaching it from that, and we're listening to the industry.
When I get into the policymakers and the taxpayers and so forth, it's really about that ROI for every single dollar that we are getting from the State of Nevada. We know at College of Southern Nevada, for every single dollar that we get from the state, it's a $2.10 return, and we just received that data on economic impact.
This Key Takeaways was produced by Chronicle Intelligence. Please contact CI@chronicle.com with questions or comments.
©2026 by The Chronicle of Higher Education Inc. All rights reserved. This material may not be reproduced without prior written permission of The Chronicle. For permission requests, contact us at copyright@chronicle.com.
