The Department of Education recently announced the approval of the nation’s first Workforce Pell Grant program at Iowa Central Community College. While traditional Pell Grants support students seeking four-year degrees, Workforce Pell funds can be used for short-term training. Their goal is to create faster, more affordable pathways to good careers.
To explore how community colleges, regional universities, and other institutions are preparing to take advantage of these grants — and navigate the challenges and limits that come with them — The Chronicle held a virtual forum on August 11. The following comments, edited for clarity and length, represent key takeaways from the forum. To hear the full discussion, watch the recorded webinar here.
Ian Wilhelm: What opportunities do you see in this federal program, and what will it require to take advantage of it at Compton College?
Keith Curry: It’s a great opportunity. Some states are already trying to figure it out — Iowa is ahead of the game. It gives us opportunities to innovate and do things differently. I’m really excited about it — and to learn from other states and colleges.
Ian Wilhelm: Kristin, how are you thinking about this?
Kristin Hultquist: Workforce Pell is part of changes to Title IV federal financial aid. Not only does it have traditional expectations for institutions about distribution and financial stability, it also starts to introduce new expectations. These are state-determined programs, and it’s expected that states will confer with a variety of stakeholders about them. They have to confer with employers and show how they’re validating that these short-term credentials will lead to good jobs. Then we have empirical metrics. For instance, we now have an expectation that 70 percent of students will complete their programs on time. We have an expectation that, six months after completion, 70 percent of the completers must be placed in a job in their field. The cost of being in the program must not exceed what someone earns. Those earnings must be more than 100 percent of the statewide poverty line after tuition and fees are paid.
States are required to put together processes for defining and then demonstrating important concepts that were heretofore not in Title IV like “stackability” and “portability.” These programs must be for in-demand and high-wage jobs. We’re going to have 50 experiences and an uneven capacity to do this. In states where the work-force board hasn’t typically worked well with community colleges, those relationships are having to get established.
Wilhelm: Elena, what does this look like in Maryland?
Elena Quiroz-Livanis: Workforce Pell is functioning almost like a stress test of how well postsecondary systems are functioning as a whole. We recently released our 2026-2030 Maryland plan for higher education. Workforce Pell is highlighting that there are friction points between “credit” and “non-credit” programs, although we don’t like using the term “non-credit” anymore. Why define something based on what it isn’t? We’re trying to use the term “professional certificate.”
Curry: What’s the most important improvement states should make to their data systems over the next two years to support Workforce Pell?
Hultquist: Everyone needs enhanced Unemployment Insurance wage record data with occupational codes. That’s not just to be able to identify programs that qualify and validate that they’ve maintained eligibility. It’s to inform long-term talent development.
If I were advising Congress — and this was being done through statute, not regulation — I’d put money aside for two things: Data-system enhancement — for an equitable distribution of opportunity based on prior state investments — and state coordinating boards and coalitions of institutions to do this change-management process. Some of the programs, you’ll determine, are going to be excellent for improving economic mobility — particularly in rural communities and for rural learners — but they’re not going to be eligible for Workforce Pell.
Quiroz-Livanis: We’ve very fortunate in Maryland to have a very robust State Longitudinal Data System (SLDS). If your state hasn’t invested in an SLDS, this is an opportunity to reconsider that. SLDS are uniquely positioned to connect K-12 education, higher education, and wage-record data. We also need business leaders to be part of the conversation and put data in the hands of students.
Curry: Andrew, how is all of this going to affect rural and regional colleges?
Andrew Koricich: The challenges to making Workforce Pell work for rural learners are severe. The requirements around program eligibility are a boon to institutions serving urban and suburban populations, but often not to rural institutions.
When you ask rural folks what they want, it’s to be able to live comfortably in the places where they are. They don’t want to have to relocate. Someone who does septic work or early-childhood education may not get paid an amount that looks impressive to a federal data system, but they’re addressing critical community needs.
Also, when talking about salaries, we don’t always do a great job differentiating between, say, $75,000 on the California coast versus $75,000 in the Central Valley. Sometimes you put markers in place and in rural areas [you] won’t hit those markers even though they’re working well. It ends up leaving out folks in the places where this work could do the most good.
Quiroz-Livanis: In Maryland, we wrested this as part of the national conversation about credentials of value. We have a community-benefit indicator. We can look at wage growth over time and ease of entry into the labor market. It’s not just about a debt-to-earnings threshold. We don’t want to lose the ability to focus on professions that may make our society better just because they don’t earn a certain annual salary.
Curry: We don’t pay them well enough. We can start having new conversations — based on Workforce Pell — about salaries for their positions.
Quiroz-Livanis: I totally agree, and we’re now equipped with data to have those conversations with business leaders. We can say, “We’re preparing graduates for you. Help them make a family-sustaining wage.”
Koricich: The data that’s going to come out of this is going to allow state agencies to have different conversations about where we’re missing the mark about what we’re investing in. There are communities where we’re failing to meet basic needs. Folks are waiting years for wells to be drilled or for septic systems — and that’s an economic-development opportunity. What if our work-force development was really targeted at things communities need more of? If you train a few well drillers, they might be a small cohort, but those are people who will do very well for a long time. How does community benefit become a metric of value in these credentials, which may be different from one place to the next based on their needs? It’s beyond wages.
Curry: I appreciate your point about what a cohort looks like. Traditionally, it’s 30 people in a classroom, but what does it look like outside the classroom?
Quiroz-Livanis: We have the opportunity to redefine so much, including teaching and learning and how it gets measured. We’re moving from credits to clock hours. We’re thinking about competency-based education, credit for prior learning, how we’re supporting adult learners.
Koricich: It’s going to be really important to approach this work with a lot of honesty about what’s working and what’s not.
Wilhelm: Tonjua and Pam, how are you thinking about these issues as college presidents?
Tonjua Williams: We’re working on innovation and creativity. We’re in an urban community — a lot of businesses are moving to the Tampa Bay area, and Florida has a master credentials list with high-wage programs, whether they’re credit or non-credit, and that’s helped us move along this pathway quickly. This is going to allow a lot of families who couldn’t afford some of the most expensive programs to get a job and a livable wage and change the trajectory of their families. I tell my team that no one comes to college to be broke, and we won’t educate students into poverty. Workforce Pell’s accountability and transparency is going to help us.
Pam Eddinger: States that are ready have all their non-credit programs lined up. I sit on a state work-force board that’s responsible for crafting parameters for credentials of value. We struggle with what I call the rule followers and the risk takers: The rule followers are narrowing their scopes so that every single program will always meet the key performance indicators. The risk takers are saying “These salaries — for, say, a certified nursing assistant or early-childhood educator — don’t measure up, but what are you going to do in society without these people?” The law and regulations aren’t nuanced, so colleges have to be agile enough to build in nuance.
Curry: How are you engaging your campus communities in a conversation about Workforce Pell?
Eddinger: I’m tamping down expectations. It’s not going to be that I have 1,000 programs tomorrow and everybody in non-credit is going to get their bill paid for. I’m encouraging us to answer the demands of “opportunity jobs,” not in-demand jobs. We don’t have a truck-driving program, because truck driving leads to more truck driving. We have a program for emergency medical technicians, which can lead to paramedics, which can lead to nursing.
Williams: Presidents are going to have to raise money for programs they’re not going to submit to be eligible for Workforce Pell. We’ve raised funds to offset the cost of those programs.
Curry: How do we prepare our campus systems to support students in these programs?
Williams: We were already giving financial aid to our clock-hour programs, so we had a jump start, but getting the data we need for this is going to be a challenge. We started with a task force, including all divisions — deans, provosts, everybody who wanted to be involved. There’s also a need to get staff ready. There’s a lot we have to think about that’s different from traditional Pell, so you have to train your teams and look at the gaps in your systems. If you have a highly enrolled program but graduates aren’t making enough money, you might have to drop that program.
The Department of Education recently announced the approval of the nation’s first Workforce Pell Grant program at Iowa Central Community College. While traditional Pell Grants support students seeking four-year degrees, Workforce Pell funds can be used for short-term training. Their goal is to create faster, more affordable pathways to good careers.
To explore how community colleges, regional universities, and other institutions are preparing to take advantage of these grants — and navigate the challenges and limits that come with them — The Chronicle held a virtual forum on August 11. The following comments, edited for clarity and length, represent key takeaways from the forum. To hear the full discussion, watch the recorded webinar here.
Keith Curry (moderator)
President
Compton College
Ian Wilhelm (moderator)
Deputy Managing Editor
The Chronicle of Higher Education
Pam Eddinger
President
Bunker Hill Community College
Kristin Hultquist
SEO & Founding Partner
HCM Strategies
Andrew Koricich
Executive Director
Alliance for Research on Regional Colleges
Elena Quiroz-Livanis
Interim Secretary
Maryland Higher Education Commission
Tonjua Williams
President
St. Petersburg College
Ian Wilhelm: What opportunities do you see in this federal program, and what will it require to take advantage of it at Compton College?
Keith Curry: It’s a great opportunity. Some states are already trying to figure it out — Iowa is ahead of the game. It gives us opportunities to innovate and do things differently. I’m really excited about it — and to learn from other states and colleges.
Ian Wilhelm: Kristin, how are you thinking about this?
Kristin Hultquist: Workforce Pell is part of changes to Title IV federal financial aid. Not only does it have traditional expectations for institutions about distribution and financial stability, it also starts to introduce new expectations. These are state-determined programs, and it’s expected that states will confer with a variety of stakeholders about them. They have to confer with employers and show how they’re validating that these short-term credentials will lead to good jobs. Then we have empirical metrics. For instance, we now have an expectation that 70 percent of students will complete their programs on time. We have an expectation that, six months after completion, 70 percent of the completers must be placed in a job in their field. The cost of being in the program must not exceed what someone earns. Those earnings must be more than 100 percent of the statewide poverty line after tuition and fees are paid.
States are required to put together processes for defining and then demonstrating important concepts that were heretofore not in Title IV like “stackability” and “portability.” These programs must be for in-demand and high-wage jobs. We’re going to have 50 experiences and an uneven capacity to do this. In states where the work-force board hasn’t typically worked well with community colleges, those relationships are having to get established.
Wilhelm: Elena, what does this look like in Maryland?
Elena Quiroz-Livanis: Workforce Pell is functioning almost like a stress test of how well postsecondary systems are functioning as a whole. We recently released our 2026-2030 Maryland plan for higher education. Workforce Pell is highlighting that there are friction points between “credit” and “non-credit” programs, although we don’t like using the term “non-credit” anymore. Why define something based on what it isn’t? We’re trying to use the term “professional certificate.”
Curry: What’s the most important improvement states should make to their data systems over the next two years to support Workforce Pell?
Hultquist: Everyone needs enhanced Unemployment Insurance wage record data with occupational codes. That’s not just to be able to identify programs that qualify and validate that they’ve maintained eligibility. It’s to inform long-term talent development.
If I were advising Congress — and this was being done through statute, not regulation — I’d put money aside for two things: Data-system enhancement — for an equitable distribution of opportunity based on prior state investments — and state coordinating boards and coalitions of institutions to do this change-management process. Some of the programs, you’ll determine, are going to be excellent for improving economic mobility — particularly in rural communities and for rural learners — but they’re not going to be eligible for Workforce Pell.
Quiroz-Livanis: We’ve very fortunate in Maryland to have a very robust State Longitudinal Data System (SLDS). If your state hasn’t invested in an SLDS, this is an opportunity to reconsider that. SLDS are uniquely positioned to connect K-12 education, higher education, and wage-record data. We also need business leaders to be part of the conversation and put data in the hands of students.
Curry: Andrew, how is all of this going to affect rural and regional colleges?
Andrew Koricich: The challenges to making Workforce Pell work for rural learners are severe. The requirements around program eligibility are a boon to institutions serving urban and suburban populations, but often not to rural institutions.
When you ask rural folks what they want, it’s to be able to live comfortably in the places where they are. They don’t want to have to relocate. Someone who does septic work or early-childhood education may not get paid an amount that looks impressive to a federal data system, but they’re addressing critical community needs.
Also, when talking about salaries, we don’t always do a great job differentiating between, say, $75,000 on the California coast versus $75,000 in the Central Valley. Sometimes you put markers in place and in rural areas [you] won’t hit those markers even though they’re working well. It ends up leaving out folks in the places where this work could do the most good.
Quiroz-Livanis: In Maryland, we wrested this as part of the national conversation about credentials of value. We have a community-benefit indicator. We can look at wage growth over time and ease of entry into the labor market. It’s not just about a debt-to-earnings threshold. We don’t want to lose the ability to focus on professions that may make our society better just because they don’t earn a certain annual salary.
Curry: We don’t pay them well enough. We can start having new conversations — based on Workforce Pell — about salaries for their positions.
Quiroz-Livanis: I totally agree, and we’re now equipped with data to have those conversations with business leaders. We can say, “We’re preparing graduates for you. Help them make a family-sustaining wage.”
Koricich: The data that’s going to come out of this is going to allow state agencies to have different conversations about where we’re missing the mark about what we’re investing in. There are communities where we’re failing to meet basic needs. Folks are waiting years for wells to be drilled or for septic systems — and that’s an economic-development opportunity. What if our work-force development was really targeted at things communities need more of? If you train a few well drillers, they might be a small cohort, but those are people who will do very well for a long time. How does community benefit become a metric of value in these credentials, which may be different from one place to the next based on their needs? It’s beyond wages.
Curry: I appreciate your point about what a cohort looks like. Traditionally, it’s 30 people in a classroom, but what does it look like outside the classroom?
Quiroz-Livanis: We have the opportunity to redefine so much, including teaching and learning and how it gets measured. We’re moving from credits to clock hours. We’re thinking about competency-based education, credit for prior learning, how we’re supporting adult learners.
Koricich: It’s going to be really important to approach this work with a lot of honesty about what’s working and what’s not.
Wilhelm: Tonjua and Pam, how are you thinking about these issues as college presidents?
Tonjua Williams: We’re working on innovation and creativity. We’re in an urban community — a lot of businesses are moving to the Tampa Bay area, and Florida has a master credentials list with high-wage programs, whether they’re credit or non-credit, and that’s helped us move along this pathway quickly. This is going to allow a lot of families who couldn’t afford some of the most expensive programs to get a job and a livable wage and change the trajectory of their families. I tell my team that no one comes to college to be broke, and we won’t educate students into poverty. Workforce Pell’s accountability and transparency is going to help us.
Pam Eddinger: States that are ready have all their non-credit programs lined up. I sit on a state work-force board that’s responsible for crafting parameters for credentials of value. We struggle with what I call the rule followers and the risk takers: The rule followers are narrowing their scopes so that every single program will always meet the key performance indicators. The risk takers are saying “These salaries — for, say, a certified nursing assistant or early-childhood educator — don’t measure up, but what are you going to do in society without these people?” The law and regulations aren’t nuanced, so colleges have to be agile enough to build in nuance.
Curry: How are you engaging your campus communities in a conversation about Workforce Pell?
Eddinger: I’m tamping down expectations. It’s not going to be that I have 1,000 programs tomorrow and everybody in non-credit is going to get their bill paid for. I’m encouraging us to answer the demands of “opportunity jobs,” not in-demand jobs. We don’t have a truck-driving program, because truck driving leads to more truck driving. We have a program for emergency medical technicians, which can lead to paramedics, which can lead to nursing.
Williams: Presidents are going to have to raise money for programs they’re not going to submit to be eligible for Workforce Pell. We’ve raised funds to offset the cost of those programs.
Curry: How do we prepare our campus systems to support students in these programs?
Williams: We were already giving financial aid to our clock-hour programs, so we had a jump start, but getting the data we need for this is going to be a challenge. We started with a task force, including all divisions — deans, provosts, everybody who wanted to be involved. There’s also a need to get staff ready. There’s a lot we have to think about that’s different from traditional Pell, so you have to train your teams and look at the gaps in your systems. If you have a highly enrolled program but graduates aren’t making enough money, you might have to drop that program.
This Key Takeaways was produced by Chronicle Intelligence. Please contact CI@chronicle.com with questions or comments.
©2026 by The Chronicle of Higher Education Inc. All rights reserved. This material may not be reproduced without prior written permission of The Chronicle. For permission requests, contact us at copyright@chronicle.com.
